The Ultimate Guide to Sunday Night Supper Club at Petunia BYOB
There’s a universally understood feeling that creeps in around late Sunday afternoon: the subtle, quiet onset of the impending work week. But what if you could replace that end-of-weekend routine with a cozy, communal feast instead?
Enter the Sunday Night Supper Club at Petunia BYOB in Cape May Court House. Part of the acclaimed Kara Restaurant Group, Petunia has reimagined Sunday night dining into an intimate, dinner party experience. Think of it as heading over to a friend’s house for a chef-curated dinner—except you bring your favorite bottle of wine, and someone else handles the dishes.
Here is your complete guide to the Sunday Night Supper Club experience, including menu details, pricing, and house rules.
What is the Sunday Night Supper Club?
The Sunday Night Supper Club is a weekly dining event designed to help neighbors and coastal visitors gather, chat, and relax over great food. Held at Petunia BYOB in historic Cape May Court House, the experience centers around communal seating.
Rather than sitting at isolated tables, guests dine side by side at shared tables. It’s an open, social setting where you can connect with friends and meet new people over a shared culinary adventure.
What’s on the Menu? A Weekly Surprise
One of the defining features of the Sunday Night Supper Club is the element of surprise.
Every single week, the chef crafts a completely fresh, secret 5-course tasting menu. Guests don’t see a menu in advance—instead, each course is revealed as it is served at the table. This surprise format gives guests a chance to step outside their comfort zone and sample ingredients, flavor combinations, and techniques they might not typically order off a standard dinner menu.
Important Note on Dietary Restrictions: Because the 5-course menu is fixed, secret, and constantly rotating—and prepped inside Petunia’s intimate kitchen—dietary restrictions, preferences, and allergies cannot be accommodated.
House Rules & Arrival Guidelines
To ensure service flows seamlessly for the entire dining room, the Supper Club operates on a strict schedule:
- One Seating Only: Doors unlock promptly at 6:15 PM for arrival and check-in.
Doors remain locked prior to 6:15 PM, so early arrivals will need to wait outside. - Service Begins at 6:30 PM: Dining room seating begins by party at 6:30 PM.
- Late Arrival Policy: Late arrivals will still be seated, but any courses that have already been served cannot be remade or replaced.
- Age & Group Limits: The Supper Club is an adults/teens experience (ages 16+ only). Party sizes are strictly limited to 6 guests or fewer.
How to Book Your Table
Because seating is limited to a single shift each Sunday, reservations fill up quickly.
- Address: Petunia BYOB, 3 Mechanic St, Cape May Court House, NJ 08210
- Cost: $50 per person (+ tax & gratuity)
- Reservations: Paid reservations required in advance via OpenTable.
Grab your favorite bottle of wine, bring an open mind, and kick off your week with new friends at Petunia BYOB.
